inglese - aggettivi e pronomi interrogativi
form
for person subject who (pron)
object whom who (pron)
possessive whose (pron and adj)
for things subject what (pron and adj)
object whiat (pron and adj)
for person and things when choise is restricted
subject which
object which
what (adjective) can be used for persons also. All this adjectives and pronouns have the same form for singular and plural.
note the who, hose + noun, what, which when used as subjects are normally followed by an affirmative not an interrogative verb :
who pays the bills ? Ann pays them
whose horse won ? The queen's horse won
which of your brothers is getting married ? Tom is
When we wish to find out who performs/performed/will perform an action, we use who ? whose ? which ? with affirmative verb.
whato ? can be used similarly
what happened ?
what went wrong ?
( but with who /what + be + noun/pronoun questions the interrogative verb is used
what day is it ?
we see that is here is interrrogative when we put the question into reported speech and it becomes
He wants to know what day it is
example of the use of who whom whose which and what in questions
who, whom, whose
who as subject
who keeps the key ?
who/whom as object
who/whom did you see ? I saw the secretary
whose
whose books are these ? They are Ann's
whose are these ? (pron)
what
as subjecte
what delayed you ? pron
as object
what paper do you read ? (adj) I read New York Time
what did they eat ? they ate rice
which
as subject
which of them arrived first ?
as object
which do you like best ?
who and whom as objects of verbs or prepositions
as direct objects
whom is the technically correct form and is used in formal written and spoken English. In ordinary conversation howether we almost Always use who so that we can say
whom did you meet ?
who did you meet ?
there is no difference in meaning but the second is much more usual than than the first
similarly we can say
whom did you help ?
who did you help?
after prepositions
In formal English the prepositions is immediately followed by whom
with whom did you go
to whom were you speaking '
But in ordinary spoken English we usually move the preposition to the end of the sentence.
whom the normally changes to who
who did you go with ?
who were you speaking to ?
what adjective and pronoun
what is a general interrogative used for things
what time is it ?
what Street is it ?
what does he want ?
when what is used with prepositions the preposition is normally placed at the end of the sentence as shown above :
what did you open it with ?
what.........for ? = why
what did you di that for ?
what+ be .......like ? is request for a description and can be used for things or people
what was the exam like ? it was very difficult
used of people it may concern either appearance or character
what is he like ? he is friendly or he was tall
what does he/it look like ? concern appearance only and can also means What does he/it resemble ?
what does he look like ? he looks like a scarecrow.
what is he ? = what is his profession
what adj used for persons is possible be not common
what men are you talking about ?
who are you talking about ? is much more usual
what adj is very common in questions about measurements. It is used in thi way chiefly with nouns age size weight lenght
what height is your room ?
what age is he ?
which compared with who and what
who is a general interrogative pronoun for persons
what is general interrogativ pronoun ad adjective used mainly for things
which pronoun and adj is used instead who and what when the choice is restricted
example of which and what used for things
what will you have to drink ?
we have gin whisky and sherry which will you have ?
example of which and who used for people
who do you want to speak to ? I want to speak with mr Smith
we have two mr Smith here john and joe which do you want ?
which pronoun of people is not used alone as subject of a verb
which of you knows the formula (of you is essential)
who knows the formula
which adj can be used of people when there is only a very slight idea of restriction
which poet do you like best ?